Wow, this is absolutely brilliant. the atmosphere, arrangement, and sample selection are spot on. The production is almost perfect and will be absolutely amazing after a proper master.

The part at 2:25 has so much emotion, it gets me every time I hear it, and I want more. I really wish I could give constructive criticism to this, but it seems perfect and seems to be the first 10 I'll be giving to ... More an artist. I'll definitely keep updated with this artists future tunes.

Fantastic atmospherics throughout this tune, complemented nicely by great work on the percussion and effects. It's lacking in the bass department generally though. The kick feels a bit weak and muffled which, coupled with the ultra-minimalistic sub-bassline (which could do with making a few more appearances here and there to really tie the tune together), gives the whole thing an awkward ... More coldness. Don't get me wrong, I understand that cold is what the atmospherics aim for, but it seems a shame that, after all the magnificent work on the other elements, the bass feels neglected and, dare I say it, lazy. It doesn't really add anything to the composition.

I would argue that taking it out altogether would work, but seeing as this is a garage tune it's actually quite an important element so my suggestion is actually to work on it

An 8 for composition, atmosphere, percussion programming and structure though. It's a haunting tune that sticks in the mind (almost surprisingly so) after a listen.